What do you think of Shiloh as a boys name?

Do you think its to feminine to be a boys name? Even tho the dog Shiloh was a boy?

What do you think of Shiloh as a boys name?
Picture a grown man named Shiloh. Cute for a boy(well, not really) but defiently not very manly.
Reply:QUEER name for a boy. Name the boy Huck
Reply:Goes either way, but Brangelina has contaminated it, so I would NEVER consider for my own kids now.
Reply:becuase of the pitt-jolie people i think of it as girly now- but it WAS a boy dog...
Reply:I know a guy named Shiloh, hes very nice.I like it for a boy. I dont think of the dog movie i think of that guy and the church i used to go to as a kid, Shiloh Baptist Church.





But i like it for a boy not girl.
Reply:i think it could work as a baby or little boy, not so sure about a grown man. i like it though, its very cute=)
Reply:Shiloh is a good name for a boy. I have always liked that name for a boy. If you like it that is all that matter's.
Reply:No, it's too girly. Would go with a more masculine name.
Reply:don't like it for either one
Reply:I like it as a boy's name. Shiloh for a girl just doesn't sound as good to me. The name Shiloh always looked like a boy's name to me even before Angelina named her girl that.
Reply:Dont you mean "Guy-Blow"?








-Grandma's Boy
Reply:Shiloh can be both a girl and a guy it's your choice
Reply:I don't like it for a boy. I also think that it will be associated with a girl because of Angelina's baby. It just doesn't sound very masculine.
Reply:Shiloh is ok for a boy. I think It can go either way. Shilah can be for a girl. If it seems too iffy, then you probably shouldnt go with it!
Reply:I love the name Shiloh and think it could go either way easily. I have always liked it and if Angelina and Brad didn't name their daughter that I don't think anyone would have ever imagined being a girls name anyway. Shiloh Evan is adorable.





Either that or,


Shiloh Isaiah


Shiloh Avery


Shiloh Ross


Shiloh Reese.





Good luck!
Reply:Sorry, Brad and Angelina coined Shiloh as a girls name last year.
Reply:I have heard it both ways.
Reply:Shiloh Isaiah
Reply:I can't say I like it for anyone, even the dog
Reply:I would name a girl name Shiloh


I would nam a boy dog Shiloh, by not a boy


Congratulaitons
Reply:Shiloh means Peace.


It's also one of the bloodiest battles of the Civil War.


You associate it with a dog.


Everyone else thinks of the daughter of Brad and Angelina.





So far, not sure why you'd go with this. How about Geoffrey or Jeffrey - also means Peace. (So does Siegfried - but I wouldn't go that route.)
Reply:Well I think that everyone will associate it with Shiloh Jolie-pitt who is a girl.


I personally do not think it is either feminine or masculine.
Reply:if its what you like its your choice i think its fine either way
Reply:not keen
Reply:Shiloh is like one of those Unisexual names like Jessie or Lynn (i know both men and women with those names) however with shiloh i'll always associate it with the dog... But if you like the name... there's no way of me (or anyone else) from stopping you. Unless it's your spouse. then they have a legitimate say in the name.
Reply:cute